Updated November 2026

Shopping for 1.5 gallon coffee filters usually means one thing: you need paper that fits a large brewer without overflow, sagging, or grounds in the carafe. This guide compares six options built for 1.5 gallon and larger drip brewers, including commercial-style machines. The selection criteria were filter dimensions relative to common brewer baskets, paper and bleaching type, pack size, and the fit patterns owners most often describe. This is a research-based comparison drawn from manufacturer specifications and brand reputation, not from hands-on testing.

Our top picks at a glance

  1. 1Katy's Extra Large Coffee Filters (12.5in x 4.5in) Commercial Business UseTOP CHOICEBest overallKaty's Extra Large Coffee Filters (12.5in x 4.5in) Commercial Business UseView on Amazon
  2. 2BUNN Commercial Tea & Paper Coffee Filters, 1.5 Gallon, 500 CountTOP CHOICEBest for commercial brewersBUNN Commercial Tea & Paper Coffee Filters, 1.5 Gallon, 500 CountView on Amazon
  3. 31.5 to 3 Gallon Large Coffee Filters - Extra Tall Walled 13.75” x 5.25TOP CHOICEBest for tall walled baskets1.5 to 3 Gallon Large Coffee Filters – Extra Tall Walled 13.75” x 5.25View on Amazon
  4. 4Tupkee Extra Large Commercial Coffee Filters, 13.75" x 5.25", 250 CountBest for chlorine-free paperTupkee Extra Large Commercial Coffee Filters, 13.75" x 5.25", 250 CountView on Amazon
  5. 5Melitta Basket Coffee Filters Natural Brown Unbleached, 100 CountBest for home drip brewersMelitta Basket Coffee Filters Natural Brown Unbleached, 100 CountView on Amazon
  6. 61-2 Cup Small Coffee Filters, 200 Pcs Basket Coffee Filters Natural UnbleachedBest budget pick (small batches)1-2 Cup Small Coffee Filters, 200 Pcs Basket Coffee Filters Natural UnbleachedView on Amazon

Our Top Picks

Quick Comparison

Product Best for Key feature
Katy’s Extra Large Coffee Filters (12.5in x 4.5in) Overall fit for 1.5 to 3 gallon brewers Extra-large footprint with a 4.5in depth
BUNN Commercial Tea & Paper Coffee Filters, 1.5 Gallon Commercial BUNN-style brewers 500-count bulk pack in a 1.5 gallon size
1.5 to 3 Gallon Large Coffee Filters, Extra Tall Walled Preventing grounds overflow 13.75″ x 5.25″ walled design
Tupkee Extra Large Commercial Coffee Filters Chlorine-free commercial use 13.75″ x 5.25″ chlorine-free white paper
Melitta Basket Coffee Filters Natural Brown Unbleached Standard home drip brewers Unbleached natural brown paper, 100 count
1-2 Cup Small Coffee Filters, 200 Pcs Basket Filters Small batches and single servings 200-piece pack for 1 to 2 cups

Katy’s Extra Large Coffee Filters (12.5in x 4.5in) Commercial Business Use

Katy's Extra Large Coffee Filters (12.5in x 4.5in) Commercial Business Use | 1.5 to 3 Gallon Brew XL Coffee/Tea Filters, For BUNN, Fetco & Curtis Commercial Machines, Proudly Woman-Owned & Gives Back

Katy's Extra Large Coffee Filters (12.5in x 4.5in) Commercial Business Use | 1.5 to 3 Gallon Brew XL Coffee/Tea Filters, For BUNN, Fetco & Curtis Commercial Machines, Proudly Woman-Owned & Gives Back

View on Amazon

Best for: Overall fit for 1.5 to 3 gallon brewers

This is a good fit for offices, cafés, and church or community kitchens that run large urns and need a filter sized beyond standard home baskets. Its extra-large footprint suits brewers that accept the wider, deeper basket format.

Key specs

  • Dimensions: 12.5 in x 4.5 in
  • Rated for 1.5 to 3 gallon commercial coffee and tea brewers
  • Listed for BUNN, Fetco, and Curtis machines

Pros

  • Large footprint covers wide commercial baskets
  • Stated for multi-gallon batches, so it scales beyond 1.5 gallons
  • Suited to tea as well as coffee

Cons

  • Too large for most home drip makers
  • Pack count is not the focus of the listing, so check quantity before ordering

Bottom line: A strong pick for businesses running large urn brewers who want one filter size across several machines.

View on Amazon

BUNN Commercial Tea & Paper Coffee Filters, 1.5 Gallon, 500 Count

BUNN Commercial Tea & Paper Coffee Filters, 20138.1000 White, 1.5 Gallon, 500 count

BUNN Commercial Tea & Paper Coffee Filters, 20138.1000 White, 1.5 Gallon, 500 count

View on Amazon

Best for: Commercial BUNN-style brewers

Offices and food-service operators with BUNN equipment often prefer filters from the same brand to reduce fit problems. The 500-count pack suits steady, high-volume use.

Key specs

  • Size: 1.5 gallon
  • Count: 500 filters
  • Designed for commercial coffee and tea use

Pros

  • Made by the brand behind many commercial brewers
  • Large bulk count lowers how often you reorder
  • Works for both coffee and tea

Cons

  • Bulk quantity may be more than small offices need
  • Size is specific to 1.5 gallon brewing rather than larger batches

Bottom line: Best for offices already running BUNN equipment that want a dependable, brand-matched filter.

View on Amazon

1.5 to 3 Gallon Large Coffee Filters, Extra Tall Walled 13.75″ x 5.25″ (500 Filter Bulk Pack)

1.5 to 3 Gallon Large Coffee Filters - Extra Tall Walled 13.75” x 5.25” to Prevent Ground Overflow - For Commercial Coffee Makers - For Businesses (500 Filter Bulk Pack)

1.5 to 3 Gallon Large Coffee Filters – Extra Tall Walled 13.75” x 5.25” to Prevent Ground Overflow – For Commercial Coffee Makers – For Businesses (500 Filter Bulk Pack)

View on Amazon

Best for: Preventing grounds overflow in tall walled baskets

If your brewer’s basket is tall and you have seen grounds spill over the sides, a taller walled filter is designed to hold more grounds without collapsing. It suits busy workplaces brewing at full capacity.

Key specs

  • Dimensions: 13.75″ x 5.25″
  • Extra-tall walled design
  • 500-filter bulk pack

Pros

  • Taller walls help contain grounds at full capacity
  • Bulk pack suits frequent brewing
  • Designed for 1.5 to 3 gallon commercial makers

Cons

  • Only useful if your basket is tall enough to accept the size
  • Bulk count is more than most home users need

Bottom line: Pick this if overflow is your main problem and your brewer has a tall basket.

View on Amazon

Tupkee Extra Large Commercial Coffee Filters, 13.75″ x 5.25″, 250 Count

Tupkee Extra Large Commercial Coffee Filters, 13.75” x 5.25”, 250 Count | XL Tall Chlorine-Free White Paper Filters, Made in USA, for Bunn, Fetco & Curtis 1.5–3 Gallon Commercial Coffee & Tea Brewers

Tupkee Extra Large Commercial Coffee Filters, 13.75” x 5.25”, 250 Count | XL Tall Chlorine-Free White Paper Filters, Made in USA, for Bunn, Fetco & Curtis 1.5–3 Gallon Commercial Coffee & Tea Brewers

View on Amazon

Best for: Chlorine-free commercial use

Buyers who want chlorine-free paper and a filter sized for 1.5 to 3 gallon commercial brewers will find this useful. The 250-count pack is a moderate quantity for smaller operations.

Key specs

  • Dimensions: 13.75″ x 5.25″
  • Count: 250 filters
  • Chlorine-free white paper
  • Listed for Bunn, Fetco, and Curtis commercial brewers

Pros

  • Chlorine-free paper suits buyers who prefer it
  • Smaller pack than bulk options, easier to store
  • Tall format helps with grounds containment

Cons

  • Smaller pack means more frequent reordering at high volume
  • Listing is oriented to commercial use, not home kitchens

Bottom line: A good middle-ground choice for small businesses that want chlorine-free paper in a moderate pack.

View on Amazon

Melitta Basket Coffee Filters Natural Brown Unbleached, 100 Count

Melitta Basket Coffee Filters Natural Brown Unbleached 100 Count

Melitta Basket Coffee Filters Natural Brown Unbleached 100 Count

View on Amazon

Best for: Standard home drip brewers

Melitta basket filters are widely sold for home machines. This unbleached natural brown option appeals to buyers who want a less processed paper and a pack size suited to household use. Confirm basket size against your machine before buying, since basket filters vary.

Key specs

  • Count: 100 filters
  • Natural brown, unbleached paper
  • Basket-style filter

Pros

  • Unbleached paper for buyers who prefer it
  • Manageable pack for home use
  • Brand is familiar to most home brewers

Cons

  • Not a commercial-scale size for 1.5 gallon urns
  • Fit should be checked against your specific basket

Bottom line: A sensible choice for a home drip brewer that needs a familiar basket filter with unbleached paper.

View on Amazon

1-2 Cup Small Coffee Filters, 200 Pcs Basket Coffee Filters Natural Unbleached

1-2 Cup Small Coffee Filters, 200Pcs Basket Coffee Filters Natural Unbleached Paper Filter for 1-2 People, Pour Over, Single Serve Coffee Makers

1-2 Cup Small Coffee Filters, 200Pcs Basket Coffee Filters Natural Unbleached Paper Filter for 1-2 People, Pour Over, Single Serve Coffee Makers

View on Amazon

Best for: Small batches and single servings

This one is sized for 1 to 2 cups, so it fits a much smaller use case than the 1.5 gallon options above. It is included because some buyers searching for large filters actually own a small brewer, and this helps avoid a mismatch.

Key specs

  • Sized for 1 to 2 cups
  • Count: 200 pieces
  • Natural unbleached paper

Pros

  • Large count at a low per-filter cost of use
  • Suited to pour-over and single-serve brewers
  • Unbleached natural paper

Cons

  • Far too small for a 1.5 gallon brewer
  • Not intended for commercial or multi-gallon use

Bottom line: Choose this only if your brewer is small. It is a useful reference point for what 1.5 gallon filters are not.

View on Amazon

Buying Guide

Filter size and brewer fit

Check your brewer’s manual or the basket dimensions before buying. A 1.5 gallon filter must fit the basket width and depth; a filter that is too narrow can leave gaps, and one that is too wide will not seat. Many commercial brewers specify filter dimensions directly.

Good picks for this: Katy’s Extra Large Coffee Filters (12.5in x 4.5in), BUNN Commercial Tea & Paper Coffee Filters, 1.5 Gallon

Basket depth and wall height

Brewers that run at full capacity push grounds toward the rim. Taller walled filters hold more grounds without collapsing, which helps reduce overflow into the carafe.

Good picks for this: 1.5 to 3 Gallon Large Coffee Filters, Extra Tall Walled; Tupkee Extra Large Commercial Coffee Filters

Paper type: bleached, unbleached, or chlorine-free

Bleached paper is brighter white, while unbleached paper is natural brown and often preferred by buyers who want less processing. Chlorine-free paper is an option for buyers who want to avoid chlorine in the bleaching process. Look at the packaging description to confirm.

Good picks for this: Tupkee Extra Large Commercial Coffee Filters, Melitta Basket Coffee Filters Natural Brown Unbleached

Pack size and reorder rate

Estimate how many brews you run per week and divide by the pack count to see how often you will reorder. Bulk packs of 500 suit busy workplaces; packs of 100 or 250 suit smaller households and offices.

Good picks for this: BUNN Commercial Tea & Paper Coffee Filters, 1.5 Gallon; 1.5 to 3 Gallon Large Coffee Filters bulk pack

Commercial versus home use

Commercial-scale filters are built for multi-gallon urns and frequent use. Home drip brewers usually take standard basket filters. Make sure the filter category matches your equipment rather than assuming any large filter will work.

Good picks for this: Katy’s Extra Large Coffee Filters (12.5in x 4.5in), Melitta Basket Coffee Filters Natural Brown Unbleached

Storage and moisture

Paper filters absorb moisture and odors from storage areas. Keep the pack sealed in a dry spot away from cleaning chemicals. Bulk packs are easier to store when the box stays closed between uses.

Good picks for this: Tupkee Extra Large Commercial Coffee Filters, 1.5 to 3 Gallon Large Coffee Filters bulk pack

Matching filter size to batch size

A filter sized for 1 to 2 cups will not hold a 1.5 gallon batch. Confirm the batch size your brewer makes, and use a filter rated for that capacity rather than trying to stretch a smaller one.

Good picks for this: 1-2 Cup Small Coffee Filters (for reference), BUNN Commercial Tea & Paper Coffee Filters, 1.5 Gallon

FAQ

What does “1.5 gallon” mean for a coffee filter?

It refers to the brewing capacity the filter is designed for, usually in commercial or large-batch brewers. Always confirm the filter dimensions against your brewer’s basket rather than relying on the capacity label alone.

Can I use a 1.5 gallon filter in a home drip maker?

Usually not. Home drip makers use smaller basket filters, and a 1.5 gallon filter is typically too large to seat properly. Check your machine’s manual for the correct filter type.

Are unbleached filters better than bleached ones?

Neither is objectively better for every brewer. Unbleached paper is natural brown and is preferred by buyers who want less processing. Bleached paper is brighter white. Choose based on your preference and your equipment’s requirements.

How do I stop coffee grounds from overflowing the filter?

Use a taller walled filter if your basket allows it, avoid overfilling the grounds, and make sure the filter sits flat and centered in the basket. Overflow is often a sign of too many grounds for the filter height.

How many filters should I keep on hand?

Divide your weekly brew count by the pack size to estimate reorder frequency. Keeping a spare pack prevents running out during busy periods.

Do chlorine-free filters brew differently?

The paper’s bleaching process does not change how the filter drains in a properly fitted basket. The main difference is the paper’s color and the processing method, so choose based on preference.

Should I rinse filters before brewing?

Some brewers recommend a quick rinse to remove paper taste and help the filter seat. Check your machine’s guidance, since instructions vary by brewer.

Conclusion

For most buyers searching for 1.5 gallon coffee filters, the first step is confirming basket size. Katy’s Extra Large Coffee Filters is a broad-fit choice for commercial brewers, while the BUNN Commercial filter suits offices already running BUNN equipment. Buyers with tall baskets and overflow issues should look at the extra-tall walled option, and the Tupkee filter suits those who want chlorine-free paper. Home drip users should consider the Melitta basket filter, and the small-batch filter is only relevant if your brewer is much smaller than 1.5 gallons.

Sources

Claire Whitaker

About Claire Whitaker

Claire Whitaker is part of our editorial team and reviews and edits our coffee gear & accessories guides, checking product details against manufacturer specifications and owner feedback.