Updated November 2026

Shopping for mr coffee water filters can be confusing, because the same brand sells several filter styles, from flat charcoal discs to multi-pack cartridges that fit different reservoirs. This guide compares six replacement options so you can match a filter to your machine, your water and how often you want to swap it. We judged each product on how well it matches common Mr. Coffee reservoir designs, the filter media it uses, pack size, and the patterns that owners tend to mention in their feedback. You will also find a buying guide that explains what to check before you order.

Our top picks at a glance

  1. 112-Pack Replacement Charcoal Water Filter Discs for Mr. Coffee Brewers Coffee MachinesTOP CHOICEBest overall12-Pack Replacement Charcoal Water Filter Discs for Mr. Coffee Brewers Coffee MachinesView on Amazon
  2. 2xcivi 12 Pack Advanced Water Filter Cartridges for Mr. Coffee Easy MeasureTOP CHOICEBest for multi-model householdsxcivi 12 Pack Advanced Water Filter Cartridges for Mr. Coffee Easy MeasureView on Amazon
  3. 3Mr. Coffee Advanced Water Filter Replacement Cartridges, White, 2-CountTOP CHOICEBest for chlorine and scale reductionMr. Coffee Advanced Water Filter Replacement Cartridges, White, 2-CountView on Amazon
  4. 4Activated Water Filter Replacement Cartridges for Mr. Coffee Makers 12-CupBest for 12-cup makersActivated Water Filter Replacement Cartridges for Mr. Coffee Makers 12-CupView on Amazon
  5. 56-Pack Replacement Charcoal Water Filter Discs for Mr. Coffee Brewers Coffee MachinesBest for small kitchens6-Pack Replacement Charcoal Water Filter Discs for Mr. Coffee Brewers Coffee MachinesView on Amazon
  6. 624-Pack Replacement Charcoal Water Filter Discs for Mr. Coffee Brewers Coffee MachinesBest budget pick24-Pack Replacement Charcoal Water Filter Discs for Mr. Coffee Brewers Coffee MachinesView on Amazon

Our Top Picks

Quick Comparison

Product Best for Key feature
12-Pack Replacement Charcoal Water Filter Discs for Mr. Coffee Brewers Most standard Mr. Coffee brewers Charcoal disc filter, 12-pack
xcivi 12 Pack Advanced Water Filter Cartridges Households with several Mr. Coffee models Cartridges sized for multiple 12-cup series
Mr. Coffee Advanced Water Filter Replacement Cartridges, White, 2-Count Reducing chlorine and calcium Two cartridges, 60-day supply
Activated Water Filter Replacement Cartridges for Mr. Coffee Makers 12-Cup 12-cup makers on a budget Activated charcoal pods, 6-pack
6-Pack Replacement Charcoal Water Filter Discs for Mr. Coffee Brewers Small kitchens and occasional brewing Smaller pack, easy to store
24-Pack Replacement Charcoal Water Filter Discs for Mr. Coffee Brewers Heavy users who want a long supply Largest pack size in this list

12-Pack Replacement Charcoal Water Filter Discs for Mr. Coffee Brewers Coffee Machines

12-Pack Replacement Charcoal Water Filter Discs for Mr. Coffee Brewers Coffee Machines

12-Pack Replacement Charcoal Water Filter Discs for Mr. Coffee Brewers Coffee Machines

View on Amazon

Best for: Most standard Mr. Coffee brewers that use a flat charcoal disc.

This is a good starting point for owners who want a straightforward replacement disc and a reasonable number of changes per year. The 12-count gives you about a year of use at typical brewing frequency.

Key specs

  • Pack size: 12 charcoal water filter discs
  • Filter type: charcoal disc for Mr. Coffee brewers

Pros

  • Simple disc design that matches many Mr. Coffee reservoirs
  • Pack size suits a full year of replacements
  • Easy to store in a drawer

Cons

  • Disc style may not fit every cartridge-based model
  • Charcoal media needs replacing on schedule to stay effective

Bottom line: A sensible default for owners who already know their machine uses charcoal discs. If you want more background, see 5 Best Ninja Coffee Machine Filters for Every Brewer (2026).

View on Amazon

xcivi 12 Pack Advanced Water Filter Cartridges for Mr. Coffee Easy Measure

xcivi 12 Pack Advanced Water Filter Cartridges for Mr. Coffee Easy Measure | Replacement Water Filter Cartridges for Dishwashable 12-Cup Coffee Makers, Fits for RF LM AM Series 12-cup Coffee Makers

xcivi 12 Pack Advanced Water Filter Cartridges for Mr. Coffee Easy Measure | Replacement Water Filter Cartridges for Dishwashable 12-Cup Coffee Makers, Fits for RF LM AM Series 12-cup Coffee Makers

View on Amazon

Best for: Small kitchens and households with several Mr. Coffee models.

Listed as compatible with Easy Measure and several 12-cup series, this pack suits people who own more than one brewer and want one filter type to cover them.

Key specs

  • Pack size: 12 water filter cartridges
  • Listed compatibility: Mr. Coffee Easy Measure and selected 12-cup series

Pros

  • Large pack covers a long stretch of brewing
  • Listed compatibility spans several models
  • Cartridge design is familiar to most Mr. Coffee owners

Cons

  • Third-party brand, so fit should be confirmed against your model number
  • Some owners report cartridges fitting loosely in certain reservoirs

Bottom line: Worth considering if you need one filter to fit more than one brewer.

View on Amazon

Mr. Coffee Advanced Water Filter Replacement Cartridges, White, 2-Count

Mr. Coffee Advanced Water Filter Replacement Cartridges, White, 2-Count | Reduces Chlorine and Calcium, 60-Day Supply, Includes Two Cartridges, For Mr. Coffee Machines

Mr. Coffee Advanced Water Filter Replacement Cartridges, White, 2-Count | Reduces Chlorine and Calcium, 60-Day Supply, Includes Two Cartridges, For Mr. Coffee Machines

View on Amazon

Best for: Reducing chlorine and calcium in hard or treated tap water.

This is the brand’s own cartridge, so fit and design match Mr. Coffee’s intended specifications. The two-count pack is a low-commitment way to try a cartridge filter.

Key specs

  • Pack size: 2 cartridges
  • Listed purpose: reduces chlorine and calcium
  • Listed supply: 60 days

Pros

  • Made by Mr. Coffee for Mr. Coffee machines
  • Clearly stated purpose for chlorine and calcium
  • Small pack is easy to try first

Cons

  • Two-count pack means more frequent reordering
  • Works only with machines that use this cartridge style

Bottom line: The safest choice for owners who want a brand-matched cartridge.

View on Amazon

Activated Water Filter Replacement Cartridges for Mr. Coffee Makers 12-Cup

Activated Water Filter Replacement Cartridges for Mr. Coffee Makers 12-Cup | Coffee Charcoal Filter Pods for Mr Coffee Machine, 6 Pcs

Activated Water Filter Replacement Cartridges for Mr. Coffee Makers 12-Cup | Coffee Charcoal Filter Pods for Mr Coffee Machine, 6 Pcs

View on Amazon

Best for: 12-cup Mr. Coffee makers where budget and steady supply both matter.

These activated charcoal pods are a practical middle ground: enough units for several months, with a format aimed at 12-cup reservoirs.

Key specs

  • Pack size: 6 pods
  • Filter media: activated charcoal
  • Designed for: Mr. Coffee 12-cup makers

Pros

  • Activated charcoal media is a common choice for taste-focused filtering
  • Pack size suits a few months of use
  • Aimed directly at 12-cup models

Cons

  • Smaller count means more frequent replacement
  • Third-party product, so confirm your model before ordering

Bottom line: A good fit for 12-cup owners who want charcoal filtration without a large commitment.

View on Amazon

6-Pack Replacement Charcoal Water Filter Discs for Mr. Coffee Brewers Coffee Machines

6-Pack Replacement Charcoal Water Filter Discs for Mr. Coffee Brewers Coffee Machines

6-Pack Replacement Charcoal Water Filter Discs for Mr. Coffee Brewers Coffee Machines

View on Amazon

Best for: Small kitchens and occasional brewing.

A six-count disc pack keeps storage simple and limits how much filter stock sits in a cupboard. It suits lighter brewing schedules.

Key specs

  • Pack size: 6 charcoal water filter discs
  • Filter type: charcoal disc for Mr. Coffee brewers

Pros

  • Compact pack takes little storage space
  • Lower commitment than larger packs
  • Same disc format as the larger charcoal packs

Cons

  • Needs reordering sooner for daily users
  • Disc fit should be checked against your model

Bottom line: A good choice for light users who want to test the disc style first.

View on Amazon

24-Pack Replacement Charcoal Water Filter Discs for Mr. Coffee Brewers Coffee Machines

24-Pack Replacement Charcoal Water Filter Discs for Mr. Coffee Brewers Coffee Machines

24-Pack Replacement Charcoal Water Filter Discs for Mr. Coffee Brewers Coffee Machines

View on Amazon

Best for: Heavy users who want a long supply and a lower cost per filter.

The 24-count pack covers roughly two years at typical home use, which makes it the most economical option when you are sure of your brewer.

Key specs

  • Pack size: 24 charcoal water filter discs
  • Filter type: charcoal disc for Mr. Coffee brewers

Pros

  • Largest supply in this list
  • Fewer reorders over time
  • Same disc design as the smaller packs

Cons

  • Large commitment if your machine turns out to need a different filter
  • Charcoal media ages even when unused, so long supplies may not all be fresh

Bottom line: Best for owners who already know their machine takes charcoal discs and brew often.

View on Amazon

Buying Guide

Filter Style: Disc or Cartridge

Mr. Coffee machines have used more than one filter format over the years. Check your reservoir or your owner’s manual before buying. Flat charcoal discs and cylindrical cartridges are not interchangeable. Ordering the wrong style is the most common mistake.

Good picks for this: 12-Pack Replacement Charcoal Water Filter Discs for Mr. Coffee Brewers Coffee Machines, Mr. Coffee Advanced Water Filter Replacement Cartridges, White, 2-Count

Model Compatibility

Mr. Coffee sells brewers in several series, including Easy Measure and 12-cup designs. Match the filter to the model number printed on your machine. Third-party filters often list compatible series, but confirm before you order.

Good picks for this: xcivi 12 Pack Advanced Water Filter Cartridges for Mr. Coffee Easy Measure, Activated Water Filter Replacement Cartridges for Mr. Coffee Makers 12-Cup

Filter Media

Charcoal (activated carbon) is widely used to reduce chlorine taste and odor. Some cartridges also list ion-exchange media aimed at calcium and scale. Read the stated purpose on the listing and match it to your water.

Good picks for this: Mr. Coffee Advanced Water Filter Replacement Cartridges, White, 2-Count, Activated Water Filter Replacement Cartridges for Mr. Coffee Makers 12-Cup

Pack Size and Replacement Schedule

Think about how often you brew. A daily user will burn through a six-count pack in a few months, while a weekend brewer may need only a few filters a year. Larger packs lower the cost per filter but tie up money if your machine changes.

Good picks for this: 6-Pack Replacement Charcoal Water Filter Discs for Mr. Coffee Brewers Coffee Machines, 24-Pack Replacement Charcoal Water Filter Discs for Mr. Coffee Brewers Coffee Machines

Water Quality

Filters reduce some contaminants and taste compounds, but they do not make every water safe to drink. If your water supply has known contamination or a boil-water notice, follow local guidance rather than relying on a pitcher or machine filter. For concerns about your water, consult your local water utility or a qualified professional.

Good picks for this: 12-Pack Replacement Charcoal Water Filter Discs for Mr. Coffee Brewers Coffee Machines, xcivi 12 Pack Advanced Water Filter Cartridges for Mr. Coffee Easy Measure

Storage and Freshness

Keep unused filters sealed in their packaging in a cool, dry place. Moisture can reduce the effectiveness of activated media over time. Large packs are only economical if you use them before the media ages.

Good picks for this: 24-Pack Replacement Charcoal Water Filter Discs for Mr. Coffee Brewers Coffee Machines, Activated Water Filter Replacement Cartridges for Mr. Coffee Makers 12-Cup

Installation and Care

Rinse new filters as the packaging directs, and soak or flush them if the instructions say so. Replace them on schedule, and descale the brewer according to the manufacturer’s guidance so that filter and machine both stay in good condition.

Good picks for this: Mr. Coffee Advanced Water Filter Replacement Cartridges, White, 2-Count, 6-Pack Replacement Charcoal Water Filter Discs for Mr. Coffee Brewers Coffee Machines

FAQ

How do I know which mr coffee water filter fits my machine?

Check the model number on the bottom or back of the brewer, and compare it with the compatibility list on the product listing. If the reservoir uses a flat disc, buy disc-style filters. If it uses a cylinder, buy cartridges.

How often should I replace the filter?

Follow the schedule in your owner’s manual. Many Mr. Coffee filters are listed with a replacement interval of roughly two months for typical use, so heavy users will replace them sooner.

Do charcoal filters remove all impurities from water?

No. Charcoal filters are mainly used to reduce chlorine taste and odor and some sediment. They are not designed to remove every contaminant, so treat them as a taste and clarity aid.

Can I use the same filter for a different Mr. Coffee model?

Sometimes, but not always. Fit varies between series. Confirm compatibility with the manufacturer’s listing or the owner’s manual before assuming a filter will work.

Should I run the filter before the first brew?

Many filters recommend rinsing or running a cycle of water through them first. Follow the instructions included with your specific product.

Are third-party filters as good as Mr. Coffee’s own?

Owners report mixed experiences. Brand-made cartridges are designed to Mr. Coffee’s specifications, while third-party options can be a sensible alternative if they clearly state compatibility with your model.

What happens if I skip filter changes?

Spent filters can stop reducing chlorine and may collect buildup, which can affect taste. Regular replacement keeps brewing water tasting cleaner.

Conclusion

For most Mr. Coffee owners, the right filter depends on two things: the style your reservoir takes and how often you brew. The 12-Pack Replacement Charcoal Water Filter Discs for Mr. Coffee Brewers Coffee Machines is a practical default for disc-style machines. The Mr. Coffee Advanced Water Filter Replacement Cartridges, White, 2-Count suits anyone who wants a brand-matched cartridge and a chance to try it. Households with several models should look at the xcivi cartridge pack, while heavy brewers may prefer the 24-count disc pack. Always confirm compatibility with your model number before ordering.

Sources

Claire Whitaker

About Claire Whitaker

Claire Whitaker is part of our editorial team and reviews and edits our coffee gear & accessories guides, checking product details against manufacturer specifications and owner feedback.