Updated November 2026

Paper coffee filters for percolator use keep grounds out of your cup without changing the flavor you expect from a stovetop brew. Percolators need filters that fit the basket or the pot bottom, hold up to repeated boiling, and resist tearing when you lift the basket. The picks below are compared on fit, material, sizing and how well they suit common percolator models.

Our top picks at a glance

  1. 1Percolator Coffee Filters for Presto Coffee Percolator Electric 12 CupTOP CHOICEBest overallPercolator Coffee Filters for Presto Coffee Percolator Electric 12 CupView on Amazon
  2. 2150 Pcs Perforated Coffee Filters for Farberware Coffee Percolator 4 CupTOP CHOICEBest for Farberware percolators150 Pcs Perforated Coffee Filters for Farberware Coffee Percolator 4 CupView on Amazon
  3. 3500 Pcs Percolator Coffee Filters for Presto Coffee Percolator 12 CupTOP CHOICEBest for high volume500 Pcs Percolator Coffee Filters for Presto Coffee Percolator 12 CupView on Amazon
  4. 4Brew Rite Wrap Around Percolator Coffee Filter 55 Ct (Pack of 2)Best for wrap-around fitBrew Rite Wrap Around Percolator Coffee Filter 55 Ct (Pack of 2)View on Amazon
  5. 5300Pcs Percolator Coffee Filter, 3.75in Unbleached Disposable Coffee FilterBest for small pots300Pcs Percolator Coffee Filter, 3.75in Unbleached Disposable Coffee FilterView on Amazon
  6. 6Melitta Super Premium Disc Coffee Filters, White, 100 CountBest for drip-style useMelitta Super Premium Disc Coffee Filters, White, 100 CountView on Amazon
  7. 7MIMORE Percolator Coffee Filters for Farberware 4-Cup, Unbleached, 150Best for a balanced thicknessMIMORE Percolator Coffee Filters for Farberware 4-Cup, Unbleached, 150View on Amazon

Our Top Picks

Product Best for Key feature
Percolator Coffee Filters for Presto 12 Cup Overall fit Perforated wavy design
Coffee Filters for Farberware 4 Cup Farberware percolators 150 perforated filters
500 Pcs Percolator Coffee Filters High volume brewing 500-count supply
Brew Rite Wrap Around Filter Wrap-around baskets 55-count, two packs
300Pcs Percolator Coffee Filter Small pots 3.75 in unbleached
Melitta Super Premium Disc Filters Disc-style baskets 100-count disc filters
MIMORE Percolator Coffee Filters Balanced thickness Wrap-around, unbleached

Percolator Coffee Filters for Presto Coffee Percolator Electric 12 Cup

Percolator Coffee Filters for Presto Coffee Percolator Electric 12 Cup | 200 Pcs, Perforated Wavy Design, Filter Paper for Moss & Stone 10 Cup, Natural Unbleached Paper, No Paper Taste

Percolator Coffee Filters for Presto Coffee Percolator Electric 12 Cup | 200 Pcs, Perforated Wavy Design, Filter Paper for Moss & Stone 10 Cup, Natural Unbleached Paper, No Paper Taste

View on Amazon

Best for: Overall fit on Presto-style 12-cup percolators.

A good match for owners of Presto-style electric percolators who want a filter sized to their basket without guesswork.

  • Pros: Wavy perforated design; natural unbleached paper.
  • Pros: Listed as producing no paper taste.
  • Cons: Fit is tied to the 12-cup basket, so it is less useful on other models.
View on Amazon

150 Pcs Perforated Coffee Filters for Farberware Coffee Percolator 4 Cup

150 Pcs Perforated Coffee Filters for Farberware Coffee Percolator 4 Cup | Percolator Coffee Filters for Coletti 6 Cup, Elite Gourmet 6 Cup, Food Grade, Prevention Coffee Grounds at Pot Bottom

150 Pcs Perforated Coffee Filters for Farberware Coffee Percolator 4 Cup | Percolator Coffee Filters for Coletti 6 Cup, Elite Gourmet 6 Cup, Food Grade, Prevention Coffee Grounds at Pot Bottom

View on Amazon

Best for: Farberware percolators with a 4-cup basket.

Suited to owners of 4-cup Farberware percolators who brew in small batches and want a generous supply on hand.

  • Pros: 150-count supply lasts a long time.
  • Pros: Perforated design is intended to keep grounds at the pot bottom.
  • Cons: Sized for smaller baskets, so it is not a fit for 12-cup pots.
View on Amazon

500 Pcs Percolator Coffee Filters for Presto Coffee Percolator 12 Cup

500 Pcs Percolator Coffee Filters for Presto Coffee Percolator 12 Cup | Perforated Filter Paper for Moss & Stone 10 Cup, Coffee Filters for Percolators, Prevent Coffee Grounds in Percolator

500 Pcs Percolator Coffee Filters for Presto Coffee Percolator 12 Cup | Perforated Filter Paper for Moss & Stone 10 Cup, Coffee Filters for Percolators, Prevent Coffee Grounds in Percolator

View on Amazon

Best for: High-volume brewing on large percolators.

Works well for households or offices that brew large pots daily and want to avoid frequent restocking.

  • Pros: 500-count supply covers heavy use.
  • Pros: Perforated paper is designed to hold back fine grounds.
  • Cons: Bulk packs take up storage space.
View on Amazon

Brew Rite Wrap Around Percolator Coffee Filter 55 Ct (Pack of 2)

Brew Rite Wrap Around Percolator Coffee Filter 55 Ct (Pack of 2)

Brew Rite Wrap Around Percolator Coffee Filter 55 Ct (Pack of 2)

View on Amazon

Best for: Wrap-around baskets that need a snug fit.

Aimed at percolator owners whose baskets need a filter that wraps the sides, not just the bottom.

  • Pros: Wrap-around shape is designed to cover the basket walls.
  • Pros: Two packs of 55 give a steady supply.
  • Cons: Wrap-around shape may not suit flat-bottomed baskets.
View on Amazon

300Pcs Percolator Coffee Filter, 3.75in Unbleached Disposable Coffee Filter

Natural Wood Pulp, Tear Resistant, Fits 3.75in Percolator Coffee Pot and Flat Baskets, Home Office Camping Use 300Pcs Percolator Coffee Filter, 3.75in Unbleached Disposable Coffee Filter

Natural Wood Pulp, Tear Resistant, Fits 3.75in Percolator Coffee Pot and Flat Baskets, Home Office Camping Use 300Pcs Percolator Coffee Filter, 3.75in Unbleached Disposable Coffee Filter

View on Amazon

Best for: Small pots and camping setups.

Fits owners of 3.75-inch percolator pots and flat baskets, including travel or camp use.

  • Pros: Unbleached natural wood pulp paper.
  • Pros: Listed as tear resistant when lifting the basket.
  • Cons: Sized for 3.75-inch baskets only.
View on Amazon

Melitta Super Premium Disc Coffee Filters, White, 100 Count

Melitta Super Premium Disc Coffee Filters, White, 100 Count (Pack of 1)

Melitta Super Premium Disc Coffee Filters, White, 100 Count (Pack of 1)

View on Amazon

Best for: Disc-style baskets and mixed brewing.

A practical choice for owners who also use drip brewers and want one familiar brand for both.

  • Pros: Established brand with a widely known disc format.
  • Pros: White paper suits everyday brewing.
  • Cons: Disc format may not match every percolator basket.
View on Amazon
Claire Whitaker

About Claire Whitaker

Claire Whitaker is part of our editorial team and reviews and edits our coffee gear & accessories guides, checking product details against manufacturer specifications and owner feedback.